Papa Carlo Pizzeria Gelati — Restaurant in Lockport

Reviews of Papa Carlo Pizzeria Gelati

• Caleb

  Added 2016.06.06

  Very good pizza. I think it is the best pizza in the Selkirk area
• Colin

  Added 2016.05.20

  Awesome food, wonderful atmosphere and the staff is awesome too
• Luis

  Added 2015.02.20

  Loved the pizza here. They were friendly and easy going when my 1 year old made a mess. Not a ton of space in the dining room but it was comfortable and not cramped. If you get there for early supper hours you likely will not have to wait. Each time we've been there, people were waiting when we left.
• Christopher

  Added 2014.07.29

  I decided to try a salad. Got a large to share. I walked out with a small foam container not full that was enough for myself. For about $15. Just salad, no meat. Never again. Sorrentos large could feed a large family for less money. I'd rather drive into the city than spend $15 on the equivalent to about 1 romaine heart with dressing. At least it was real cheese. First impression was terrible. Cute place though. Pretty empty. Might get more traffic if you lowered the prices. I live across the highway ands won't waste my money on a craving again.
• Nathaniel

  Added 2013.07.20

  Bread was melt in your mouth! Ceasar salad dressing tasted like home made. Pizza was delicious!!